Chapter 24b
Train to
“Hope we didn’t wake you up,”
said Hapgood.
“Yes, the Jews seem to depend on revealed law. So, in fact, do the Muslims. If it is in the Koran, it isn’t supposed to
change. Not many years ago, while doing
renovations in a mosque the workers discovered a large number of copies of the
Koran going back over several centuries.
As you might expect, they could trace subtle changes creeping into the
text over the years. But the Koran was
not supposed to evolve. It was supposed
to be fixed. The discovery made a lot of
people unhappy, and there was a big flap about it. I don’t know what finally happened to the old
texts. I can’t believe they were
destroyed, but I have never seen them all published side by side either.”
“Indeed,” said Hapgood. “Certainly
the tone changes over time. But the
Hebrews kept everything, whether it seemed to conflict with other things or
not. That is one of the things that make
the Bible such a powerful book.
It’s all there, warts and all, and I do not mean that in an irreverent
fashion. You may have a quarrel with
this passage or that, but you have to respect the fact that they put the
difficulties right out there where you could see them. That implies a basic honesty that is without
equal in any other serious document I am aware of. The field of science as a whole might
compare, but generally an individual paper is written with a conscious slant
and an attempt at complete consistency.”
“What about the constitution
of the
“That’s a good point,” said Hapgood. “There are
amendments that change it. In fact the
ability to change it was written into the constitution from the beginning. They never expected it to be an absolute
standard. That, of course, casts a
shadow over the times when the courts decide they are going to make an
effective change in the constitution without going through the process of an
amendment. One could object that they
overstep their powers, but of course they claim the right to be the ones to
decide just what their powers are, so any objection is going nowhere without an
amendment.
“There again, you have to
respect the Hebrews. At least they made
no secret of the fact that they were calling on God for an opinion rather than
on the vote of the people. There’s that
honesty again.”
Hapgood said, “Yes.
There is the power of the perfect observer, even if all He does is observe.
“That brings up an
interesting point. Remember we learned
at
“And then some,” thought
“There are those who claim
that we do not have conscious will. When
the test is done, the will does appear to be a delusion. But just who is being deluded? Is our consciousness actually God looking out
though our own eyes and seeing the world as He knows it is? When we feel we are making a choice, is it
God making a judgment of our actions, and are our actual actions simply being
carried out by a sort of automaton?
These are difficult questions.”
“There is another spooky
thing about God as the observer,” said Hapgood. “You remember I said that I find it
unsettling that the universe essentially began as a flash of light, as in ‘Let
there be light.’”
“Yes, of course,” said
“Well the next thing that God
did was to see the light. Now modern
physics distinguishes between two states of reality. There is the quantum world in which
everything is uncertain, and there is the classical world in which things
behave the way we understand them to in ordinary life. Things go from an uncertain state to a
classical state when they are observed or when they interact with the classical
world.
“But if everything began as a
flash of light, there was no observer to see the light and no classical world
with which the light could interact.
Light, until it is observed or interacts with the classical universe, is
completely in a state of quantum uncertainty.
So how did the classical world begin?
Who made the Great Observation that made the knowable universe
possible?”
“God,
of course,” said
“You
say of course, but that implies a God that can be inferred from science. That would be quite a stretch for most
scientists these days.”
“Difficult,”
said
They fell silent as the train
rustled eastward. About nightfall, they
were in
There have been 5,905
visitors so far.